Past Your Breaking Point: Overcoming Injuries as a Student-Athlete

By Jacob Everix

Fall 2024

As student athletes, we are constantly faced with daily challenges, presented to ourselves both on and off the field. From balancing our academic workloads and rigorous training schedules, to dealing with the pressures of competition, our journeys are shaped through the peaks and troughs of adversity. As any athlete knows, perhaps one of the most daunting hurdles to face is overcoming sports injuries. The grueling physical pain, hardships of the mental strains, and the unknowing fears of not being capable of returning to your sport can become quickly overwhelming.

These feelings are most familiar to Jake Figurski, a North Central College junior football student athlete, and Ciré Smith, a North Central College sophomore track & field student athlete. As both high school and collegiate student athletes, Jake and Ciré are no strangers to the enduring hardships brought forth by their athletic injustices. Back in high school, Jake experienced a major concussion that took him out of his whole football season, limiting his cognitive skills and confusing his emotions when responding to an unseen injury. Ciré on the other hand is currently recovering from a stress fracture in her foot as she ran through the pain following her most recent Spring track season, enduring constant uncertainties in treatment methods. Despite experiencing different physical afflictions, these injury-prone phases of doubt and crisis can mold the uplifting of renewed resilience and inspirational character development in injured athletes.

Adjusting to Curveballs

Sports injuries, no matter the sport or individual’s athletic status, are practically inevitable, especially when competing at higher levels like in collegiate athletics. According to the Journal of Amateur Sport, reportable injuries are typically defined as injuries that:

  1. Occur as result of participation in organized athletic practice or competition

  2. Require attention of an athletic trainer, physician, or physical therapist

  3. Result in restriction of an athlete’s participation in their sport

For younger athletes like college students, dealing with a sports injury and having to quit playing the sport they love can be extremely disheartening. Many student athletes often experience injury-related consequences that are affiliated with no longer participating in their sport, including loss in sense of identity, deprivation of self-esteem, and deficiencies in proper stress management.

When experiencing the initial response to a sports injury, many athletes can often get overwhelmed with not just physical pain, but spiraling mental thoughts and differing emotional states. During this time, many injured athletes can have the tendency in focusing too much on the “uncontrollables” during initial injury response: the “could haves”, “shouldn’t haves”, and “if onlys” of getting hurt and injured in play or competition. The hyper fixation of these possible outcomes only takes the athlete away from their current situation by spending too much of their time and energy fixating on a different outcome. By accepting the reality of the specific sports injury, you can start to properly embrace the early emotions of your athletic injustices.

Emotions are also an essential part of the healing process so allow yourself to have time towards mourning or feeling loss in the moment during the initial impact phases. Studies from the International Journal of Science and Education show that hiding or burying early feelings can ultimately interfere with the mental coping during the later stages of your recovery process. Through proper situational analysis in the initial impact phase, athletes can be successful in moving forward on the start of their recovery process.

The Road to Recovery

The key first step in successfully overcoming a sports injury is developing a recovery process. Each recovery process is individualized to best tailor the needs of the individual athlete, specific sport, or type of injury. Dr. Brittany James, North Central College’s Assistant Director of Athletics for Health Care & Director of Sports Medicine, has worked with countless student athletes at North Central to aid in their healing process and help them return to play/competition in their sports. In our interview, Brittany exemplifies her outlook on working with student athletes, saying, “Knowing a patient before they become a patient is often most inviting. Creating positive spaces to interact and advocate with athletes, injured or not, works to help them understand value in their sports and long-term health.” By working alongside coaches, other trainers, and the athletes themselves, Brittany helps to generate a fitted recovery process around the athlete’s needs, familiarity, team sport training perspectives, and athletic goals. Having a thorough and developed recovery process helps injured athletes stay motivated and on-track to successfully navigate their path to recovery.

Stages of Physical Recovery

While each sports-related injury has differing levels of physical pain, strain, and length of recovery, physiotherapists have complied 5 different stages associated with providing proper intervention towards the actions of physical recovery:

Stage 1: Pain Management

The primary focus of Stage 1 is addressing pain symptoms and protecting the athlete from further physical trauma through offloading movement and resting the afflicted area(s). Common uses of intervention by physiotherapists include RICE tactics (Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation), manual pain reduction therapy, and stretching exercises.

Stage 2: Mobility Restoration

After assessing the athlete’s condition, physiotherapists often begin restoring the athlete’s range of motion to help regain necessary flexibility and joint mobility. There are many simple activities used across many different sports that utilize muscle strengthening, flexibility, and therapeutic exercises during the return to movement in Stage 2.

Stage 3: Increasing Strength & Stamina

Stage 3 often involves most of the physical injury pain becoming obsolete and allowing the athlete to begin increasing their muscle strength and endurance for their return back to sport. Physiotherapists often involve both form and posture control into common bodyweight exercises to accurately maintain effective comebacks of both strength and endurance. 

Stage 4: Reconnecting Coordination/Technique

The rehabilitation process of sports injuries will now require specialized sport proprioception, which is defined as the body’s ability to put together movement, action, and ability in intuitive and automatic ways to increase reconnection to body self-awareness. Stage 4 intervention utilizes various movements like single-leg stances for neuromuscular control, but can often depend on the necessary conditioning needed in the specific sport.

Stage 5: Return to Play/Competition

The final stage of the recovery process involves the athlete’s full/near full physical recovery completed for successful return to play or competition in their sport. Assessing new athlete conditions may involve precise return conditions set by physiotherapists or athletic trainers, including competition timeline factors or full practice requirements. 

Throughout the entire recovery process, injured athletes should be mindfully active to embracing the “little things” toward successful recovery and post-injury prevention. Factors influencing mindful recovery include optimizing a proper sleep schedule, having a balanced nutritional diet, proper hydration, and strength & conditioning training. Brittany James emphasizes the importance of these factors as being the most beneficial for all athletes across all different sports. Brittany believes, “When you are injured, your body is still working hard to get back to homeostasis. These practices will not only help aid your injury recovery, but will help prevent future injuries as well.” Applying these habits into your normal lifestyle as a student athlete will keep yourself mindfully active to recovery; hopefully avoiding another future injury in your athletic career.

Many athletes can often get overwhelmed with not just physical pain, but spiraling mental thoughts and differing emotional states . . . By accepting the reality of the specific sports injury, you can start to properly embrace the early emotions of your athletic injustices.

Mental Conditioning

While the physical components of injury rehabilitation are often portrayed for successful recovery, there are huge mental challenges associated with sports injuries that shouldn’t be overlooked in injured athletes. According to Erin Haugen from Operative Techniques in Sports Medicine, approximately 1 in 5 individuals experience mental health difficulties each year, with over 75% beginning at the age of 24 in young adults. Coping with mental health isn’t simply defined as “thinking positively” but requires stronger and more mindfully active techniques to keep yourself both positive when faced with adversity and more grateful for everything life continues to offer you, rather than staying stuck on your current setbacks.

Dealing with athletic injuries regularly poses significant mental and emotional challenges for the wellbeing of injured athletes. Al Carius, North Central College’s former Head Cross Country and Track & Field Coach, understands the complexities around navigating the psychological impacts of sports injuries, and shares invaluable insights on his philosophy regarding mental resilience and maintaining emotional well-being during the adversities of life. In a discussion with Al, he expresses, “Life itself isn’t linear; it’s filled with constant ups and downs, and roadblocks testing your daily strength and will. But when you take time to look at yourself, you’ll come to realize you learn far more from the pain adversity and difficulties than the upsets.” Regardless of sport or injury severity, undertaking sports injuries is often both daunting and distracting from reality so making daily improvements can keep yourself in good mental health. Al continues, “Being who you are right now in the moment and working to be a little bit better each day will keep you moving toward your major goals and appreciating all the little things you have to be grateful for.” Looking for ways to make “everyday a win” can be hard but there are different coping mechanisms that have been proven effective in improving your overall well-being whilst you return back to sports.

Coping Methods

Managing Your Emotions

During the initial phase of injury impact, embracing those early emotions is key for better understanding your injury. Now in the midst of active recovery, eliminating negativity surrounding your injury is essential for your healthy mindset. Keep your differing emotions in perspective and uplift all the positives while eliminating the negatives.

Setting Achievable Daily Goals

These are goals to keep yourself mindfully motivated toward taking recovery as serious as your sport. These goals shouldn’t be set on a timeline but should be built around successful progress; being as simple as getting yourself out of bed and dressed in the morning. Daily goal setting keeps you focused on what you have control over for mental toughness building.

Elevating Your Identity

Student athletes can often find themselves feeling lost without their sense of identity. There are many powerful ways to elevate your sense of personal identity and make yourself more well-rounded as an individual person, rather than just an athlete. Improving your academic performance, increasing your social network, becoming involved in your community, and discovering new hobbies can all lead to stronger mental engagement, while adding tremendous amounts of positive influences into your lifestyle.

Being Optimistic

Keeping a positive attitude toward your situation is fundamentally key in maintaining a healthy and active mindset during your recovery. Understanding that you are not alone in your fight, and you are more than just your sport alone will help you continue to enjoy life. Optimism provides a greater outlook to see all you have to be grateful for which far extends the dreads of your sports injury.

Rallying Your Team

While upholding an active rehabilitation process and maintaining a positive mindset are key in overcoming any sports injury, another critical influence in the effectiveness of an athlete’s recovery is the strength of their support system: family, friends, teammates, coaches, professional trainers, and more, can all aid in the injury healing process. Brian Johnson, North Central College’s Assistant Athletic Director for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion, knows first and foremost how vital athletic support and inclusion within an athlete’s support systems is, especially when dealing with sports injuries. In our interview, Brian conveys, “All sports aren’t created equally and push through differing demands without equal representation. All athletes of different backgrounds experiencing different injury journeys deserve mental health exploration, positive influence, and feelings of belonging.” Brian offers program initiatives like Critical Conversations and UBelong series through North Central College to give both athletes in or away from competition equal representation and acknowledgement. Support in emotional well-being can be gifted from different external sources, but can often require both sides working to cooperate and make conscious efforts toward positive inclusivity.

The benefits of a strong support system far exceed the physical rehabilitation as they fulfill essential roles of emotional encouragement necessary to maintain positive outlooks. From professional expertise in offering tailored strategies in pain management and setting realistic goals, to fellow teammates and athletes who could provide insights from firsthand experiences, these networks can help injured athletes avoid isolation, offer practical advice, and maintain their identity. Brian Johnson continues, “Sometimes, managing your feelings during recovery takes it setbacks. While you shouldn’t go looking for those external bucket fillers, knowing that you are supported, being heard, and feeling like you belong are essential for measuring successful recovery.”

Athletic inclusion can often go overlooked when overcoming a sports injury, but can greatly influence positive stimulation in injured athletes by keeping them involved with their teams. When fostering supportive team culture, Brian believes, “Both sides need to make conscious efforts towards cooperation and engagement. Instilling comradery and having new experiences around their teams can encourage better mentality and involvement integrities for injured athletes.” Al Carius adds, “Leadership often comes from what you do; not from what you say. Building that credibility when helping others will help yourself more in return as you give more than you receive.” Whether you’re battling an injury or performing at your best, there’s always someone struggling through adversity who could benefit from insightful peer support and impactful team comaradery.

Lessons from the Sidelines: Strategies to Manage Your Athletic Adversities

While every sports injury is uniquely different and arduous, almost every athlete experiences the same physical and mental hardships associated with their own individual injury. I faced these trials of adversity in Spring 2024 when I shattered one of my metatarsals in my foot trying to qualify for the Indoor National Track Championships. The fracture took me out of competition and running altogether for the rest of the semester; with a majority of it spent in a walking boot. During the entirety of the ordeal, I lost seasonal milestones, respect from my teammates, leadership opportunities, and a sense of my own self-identity as my recovery time prolonged. Thanks to the guidance and gracious help from my physical therapist, I was able to start running toward the start of July; 5 months after the original fracture break.

Whether dealing with an athletic career breaking injury, your typical seasonal injury, or simply just overcoming the daily struggles of life itself, there are always opportunities presented to us to continue striving toward success. As Brian Johnson states, “Athletics is simply a tool to teach lessons of life. The combination of personal, physical, and mental recovery instills positive growth.” Sports injuries can provide a new opportunistic outlook to take a step back and reapply yourself back into your journey of personal development, both on and off the field. Al Carius responds back, “Those life lessons not only make you a stronger athlete, but a better person fit to tackle the more serious life adversities.” Looking back on my own personal recovery phase, this journey has taught me some invaluable takeaways that I personally believe are essential to not only managing your own athletic injury, but also navigating the daily challenges of life itself.

Finding Strength in Misfortune

When confronting the various challenges of life, finding inner strength during times of adversity is pivotal for developing resilience and fostering self-improvement. When asked how to find strength in misfortune, Brian Johnson commented, “Give yourself time and grace through failure as the final outcome doesn’t have to look like you envisioned it. Not everyone’s journey will look the same and if you fall publicly or privately, time and grace will grant you perspective.” This original point of view will provide more opportunities to continue transforming misfortune into accomplishment.

Building Your Mental Toughness

Developing robust mental toughness is vital for conquering life’s physical and psychological obstacles, promoting long-term success and emotional stability. When asked about building mental toughness, Brittany James stated, “Injury forces you to slow down, allowing yourself to open up to new experiences or insights from other people in similar situations. While each situation is unique, you learn how you individually process the outside world and can begin approaching new things to instill future preparedness.” Intuitional readiness facilitates stronger adaptation and perseverance when navigating new, imposed hardships.

Turning Trials into Opportunities

Embracing adversity as a new opportunity for developing individual growth is key for maximizing any situation and promoting both personal and professional progression. When asked how to make the most of unfamiliar situations, Al Carius replied, “Happy people think about and appreciate the goodness within their lives, rather than dwelling on the negatives. Positive thoughts cultivate new feelings, leading to better words, improved actions, and thoughtful reflections.” Shifting your perspective to recognize the positive aspects of your life is essential to making the most out of any situation you encounter.

Final Thoughts

When it comes to successfully overcoming injuries during your athletic career, Jake Figurski and Ciré Smith are certainly no exceptions in adapting against their trials of hardships. Through consistent exposure to supportive team energy, Jake was able to continue providing beneficial strength towards his team and sport, while still embodying his radiant positivity into other campus communities at North Central, despite his career ending setbacks. Ciré continues to face injury complications, but through unbreakable coach and teammate relationships, Ciré is cherishing the collegiate athletics lifestyle and culture, with inspirational positivity, love, and motivation toward a promising and fulfilling college track career. Both student athletes have expressed higher appreciation towards their athletic careers and relationships while embracing the greater gratitude’s of life itself over just outcomes around winning.          

Injury prevention is a critical aspect of long-term athletic health, ensuring that all athletes can perform at their best without the setbacks of physical trauma. Brittany James continues to commend long-term health benefits through the education and wellness strategies on injury prevention. Brittany advocates, “Long-term health is more about you as a person, so valuing your next step of your sport and athletic career helps athletes develop as better people, physically and mentally healthy long-term.” These sports injuries provide invaluable life lessons in understanding how everyone is unique but not alone when fighting through adversities, as well as embracing new opportunities to strengthen your relationships and induce positive growth through challenges.

In our discussion, Al Carius emphasizes one of the fundamental elements of his coaching philosophy, remarking, “In the end, you are just working every day to make the most of your God given gifts and God given talents to become the best version of you that you can be, in both athletics and in life.” The hardships faced when overcoming sports injuries, especially as a student athlete, are just another part along your journey of personal development; guiding and preparing you for the next stages of your life whilst becoming a greater version of yourself. So, whether you’re a fellow student athlete facing similar obstacles or you are just simply trying to find motivation through the daily challenges of life, I hope my own journey, as well as the thoughtful insights from some inspirational people here at North Central College, will resonate with you, providing some guidance and positive encouragement as you keep pushing past your breaking point.

Jacob Everix is a senior student-athlete at North Central College, pursuing a bachelor’s degree in Environmental Sustainability. Jacob is also a member of the Men’s Cross Country and Track & Field teams, competing in these sports for over 12 years.

Jacob’s running journey took an unexpected turn in Spring 2024 when he fractured his foot toward the end of his junior year Indoor Track season. For the remainder of his track season and into his senior year, Jacob faced the daunting road to recovery, experiencing many physical and mental challenges. These injury hardships tested Jacob’s strength and resilience; sparking a new commitment to inspire and help other athletes navigate their own paths to recovery.

Through physical therapy and unwavering support from friends and family, Jacob overcame his injury setback and emerged stronger, both on and off the track. Outside of academics and athletics, Jacob is the Vice President of Focus, Sustainability Liaison of Green Scene, and runs his own small art and photography business.